Photo by Levi Meir Clancy / Unsplash

Compassion and Contempt in Response to Chaos and Antisemitism

Podcast Oct 30, 2023

In a time when our society is so divided, especially in America, and with all the geopolitical tensions happening, I can't help but wonder if there's a way for us to come together and live in unity. We're seeing calls for violence and growing antisemitism, which is deeply concerning. It's hard to make sense of it all.

I question whether compassion is the same as pity. When we show compassion, we try to understand others and their needs, just like we do with infants who can't communicate verbally. But do these factions really understand the consequences of their actions? Are they just engaging in some sort of costume play without fully grasping the reality of the situation?

I also ponder the role of open-mindedness and closed-mindedness. While it's important to be open-minded, is there a place for closed-mindedness to preserve tradition and what is good? How do we stay open-minded to movements like intifada while still upholding democracy?

There are clear moral differences between the sides involved in these conflicts. One side uses children as human shields, while the other tries to protect civilians. It's not about declaring moral superiority, but rather recognizing the stark differences in their actions.

I find it perplexing when people support causes that would oppress them if they were in those countries. For example, holding signs supporting LGBTQ rights in Palestine, where they would face persecution, while in Israel they would be free to live their lives. It's an inversion of logic that can be attributed to the Marxist class struggle being superimposed onto other conflicts.

But are these demonstrators consciously aware of the frameworks they're adopting? I believe that much of it is childlike cosplay rather than a well-thought-out ideology. And sometimes, empathy is not about gratification but about setting boundaries and saying no, as Larry Summers did when he distanced himself from Harvard.

As I reflect on my peaceful weekend and the tangible work I did, I can't help but notice the disconnect from reality that many people, especially the younger generation, seem to have. Engaging in pixelated simulations of reality instead of experiencing the physical and material world makes it difficult for them to understand what's really going on.

So, the question remains - how do we connect with our neighbors who are out of touch with reality? How do we reach out to them without getting too far astray ourselves? It's a challenge, but it's important to keep the ideal of making contact with them in some way.

That's all for today, folks. Take care, and I'll catch you in the next episode.

The Real Clear Podcast with Dr Lucas Klein is the in-depth analysis and commentary on current political events through a psychological lens. The Real Clear podcast covers a wide range of topics, from the latest election results to policy debates, to exploring the impact of current events on the political landscape.


compassion, divided, America, geo-military problems, globalizing, intifada, violence, Jews, Ithaca, progressive area, Cornell, Ithaca College, strange behavior, American politics, New Orleans, pro-Palestinian marauders, Israeli flag, London, demonstrate, Chicago, pro-Israel, pro-Hamas, violent fight,senility, decline, political fugitive, unity, antisemitism,hospitals, schools, Israeli state,
civilians, differences,contact, neighbors, reality, drifted, ideal